Does CiviCRM make it possible to specify which directories are private and which are public-accessible?

This is currently not possible in CiviCRM. A PAAS like Pantheon provides a specific folder for private file uploads and we can't change it to any other folder. However, CiviCRM assumes that the site is either running on Apache (and it can use .htaccess files) or that custom NGINX rules can be set. This is an unreasonable expectation.

CiviCRM requires some filepaths to be private and will complain if they're not configured properly: https://civicrm.org/advisory/civi-sa-2014-001-risk-information-disclosure

CiviCRM has hardcoded the filepaths of some things based on the path of CIVICRM_TEMPLATE_COMPILEDIR. The problem is that CIVICRM_TEMPLATE_COMPILEDIR needs to be private but many of the files that CiviCRM is trying to write based on that path need to be publicly available (e.g. dynamically written JS).

An audit of both baseFilePath() and CIVICRM_TEMPLATE_COMPILEDIR: audit-template_compiledir.txt.

Tim provided some technical guidance in another thread cloud-native#1 (comment 3124):

• The references to baseFilePath() in CRM_Utils_System_* should become irrelevant if civicrm.settings.php has the $civicrm_paths['civicrm.files']

• The references to baseFilePath() in CRM_Utils_File::absoluteDirectory and ::relativeDirectory already appear to be irrelevant within civicrm-core. (The only usage I could find was one which explicitly set its own base.)

• The reference to baseFilePath() in CRM_Core_Config_Runtime is more effort. I don't know if it'd work, but my first try would be (a) lookup a path-variable like Civi::paths()->getVariable('civicrm.log', 'path'), (b) declare the variable in Civi\Core\Paths, (c) change the relative boot order of Civi\Core\Paths and CRM_Core_Config_Runtime.

• I think CRM/Utils/Cache/SerializeCache.php is unused.

• The CRM/Core/IDS.php line feels silly. We should pick one folder! Pointing that at templates_c makes as much sense as uploadDir. (TBH, I'm not sure does anything now that Config.IDS.ini has been killed.)

• Civi/Core/Container.php and CRM/Extension/ClassLoader.php are very similar to the Smarty use-case (i.e. writing out ephemeral PHP files to take advantage of opcode caching).